Showing posts with label work discrimination. Show all posts
Showing posts with label work discrimination. Show all posts

Saturday, November 13, 2010

Coming Out at Work Remains a Dangerous Prospect

An article in the Guardian looks at the continued difficulty that far too many LGBT employees experience in the workplace: the fear of the consequences of coming out. Even in states and countries that afford non-discrimination protections, coming out can be a career killer because of all the insidious ways that homophobic superiors aand/or co-workers can undermine one's job security. Where there's a will to fire someone, with time and subtrifuge, it can be done. In the long term, I believe that the USA's failure to match the employment protections becoming more and more common in other nations will hurt the nations competitiveness in the global economy. The best and the brightest from other nations don't want to live under a pall of bigotry. For the time being, coming out at work can be daunting.
*
So the question becomes one of "should I come out at work or not?" Having been in the closet at work I know first hand the added daily stress it factors into the mix, thus impairing job productivity. Moreover, it's hard to build true comraderie with co-workers when you cannot be honest about yourself or your partner and family. In my case, I did ultimately came out at work and it was fine until my law firm was basically acquired by a firm called Wolcott & Rivers and I was booted. In the view of bigots within that firm, an openly gay partner might offend the sensibilities of conservative clients. I have my own law firm now and the irony is that clients do not seem to give a damn whether or not I'm gay or straight. In fact, I have found that minority clients of all types - including Mulsims - often seem more comfortable with my firm simply because they do not feel they will face any form of discrimination. Something that assuredly is not true at many of the larger area law firms where bigotry remains alive and well despite pretenses to the contrary.
*
So what does an LGBT employee do? It comes down to a personal choice of how you want to live. With laws like DADT daily telling the larger public that anti-gay discrimination is perfectly fine, know that there are very real risks involved in backward states like Virginia. On the other side of the equation is the liberation that goes with not having to hide who your are all day, every work day. Here are highlights from the Guardian article that reflect a far better situation in the UK than here in America:
*
"Coming out is still a huge risk for a lot of people, especially in blue collar industries and smaller businesses, but with businesses becoming more switched on and the next generation expecting more equality, things are changing," he says.
*
Stonewall runs an Equality Index for workplaces – normally for those with 500 staff or more that have the best policies – and also has a leadership programme to help gay people. "People at the top are often the most scared about coming out because they feel they have the most to lose," says Thomas.
*
He says that while those on the index have some very impressive policies and initiatives aimed at making LGBT staff feel more comfortable, general diversity training in UK workplaces is often more focused on issues of race rather than sexuality, which leads to a lack of confidence.
*
But even at workplaces with strong policies, some staff are not happy to come out, as Gemma, a gay accountant in London knows. She says that despite her company's high ranking on the Stonewall index, she doesn't have enough trust in her managers to be honest about her sexuality. "It's a very straight, conservative working environment. There is an LGB group but it is virtually invisible, unless you specifically seek it out. And, there is rarely any internal publicity about what the group is and what it can do for staff," she says.
*
Even in higher education, only 38% of staff are comfortable enough to come out – and 34% have been treated negatively because of their sexual orientation, according to research by the Equality and Human Rights Commission last year.
*
Changing attitudes is partly about the visibility of LGBT people in the workplace, says Thomas. "I would always encourage people to come out at work if they can, because it's good for others in the company who might be gay to see representation." He is also keen to encourage LGBT people to see that their sexuality can be pitched as an asset. "Plenty of companies and organisations appreciate the value of a diverse workforce. They know that allowing staff to feel comfortable about who they are makes them more productive," he says.
*
Confidence is likely to increase further following the introduction of the Equality Act 2010 last month. This act is designed to strengthen LGBT employee rights and promises to take direct and non-direct sexuality discrimination more seriously. It is another milestone we can be thankful for, particularly when we look at the situation in countries such as the US, where – shockingly – you can still be sacked for being gay in 28 states.
*
Yes, people do notice the legalized bigotry in the USA. I suspect more and more people around the world are coming to see that America's image of itself as land of the free and a nation with religious freedom for all is a huge lie.

Thursday, November 08, 2007

Personal Thoughts on ENDA

I must admit that I was a little teary eyed when I posted about ENDA passing the U. S. House of Representatives last night. Nearly no week goes by when I do not get an inquiry from someone who has been fired or fears being fired in Virginia due to their sexual orientation. Job discrimination and Don't Ask, Don't Tell are all part of the Far Right's agenda to keep LGBT individuals stigmatized and marginalized. This type of legalized discrimination certainly has helped hurt me in my divorce case. I greatly believe that had I left the marriage for another women, my treatment would be FAR different. Instead, I am faced with an atmosphere where the "faggot" should be punished - because the law says they are not equal.
I believe that it is because of the impact that equal employment protection will in time have on the public mindset towards gays that has motivated the Christianist and GOP opposition. Once it is no longer legally possible to discriminate against gays, a gradual change in overall attitude will follow. Our enemies know this. Hence the hysteria to stop ENDA. I like this comment that Andrew Sullivan noted on his blog which sums it up (http://andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com/the_daily_dish/2007/11/enda-passes-the.html):
The Republicans - exempting 35 of them - did their best to link employment non-discrimination to marriage rights, expressing their usual spite toward those gay couples who have dared to commit to one another in law and love, by a legislative distraction. But they failed in the end. And most of us are used to the abuse by now. We do not need their affirmation to love one another. But some do still need some framework of protection in order to work without fear - especially in those states where gay couples have been targeted as public threats to the family.
It is truly sad when citizens find themselves "used to abuse" in a society that claims to stand for freedom and equality.

Thursday, November 01, 2007

Study finds working “in the closet” hurts both employee and employer

The nonpartisan Rockway Institute, which conducts research on LGBT policies and programs in order to provide scientific, accurate information to the media and lawmakers, has released a new report on a study done concerning gays in the closet at work. From my own experience, I have to agree with what the stress of fear of discovery and the possible negative consequences do to you. You are not yourself, nor are you at your best and most creative. Here are highlights of the findings:
A questionnaire study of more than 500 gay, lesbian and bisexual employees across the U.S. has found that “fears about disclosing a gay identity at work had an overwhelmingly negative relationship with their career and workplace experiences and with their psychological well-being.”

The researchers, Belle Rose Ragins and Romila Singh of the University of Wisconsin – Milwaukee and John M. Cornwell of Rice University, wrote “these findings were both striking and disturbing; those who reported more fear of the negative consequences of full disclosure had less positive job and career attitudes, received fewer promotions, and reported more physical stress-related symptoms than those who reported less fear.” The article, “Making the Invisible Visible: Fear and Disclosure of Sexual Orientation at Work,” was published in The Journal of Applied Psychology (2007, Vol. 92, No. 4, 1103-1118).
The researchers Ragins, Singh, and Cornwell concluded that deciding whether to come-out is an exceptionally difficult career challenge facing lesbian/gay employees that typically goes unnoticed by employers. However, the threats to employment security are real. There are no laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation in 31 states, and such discrimination remains “widespread” in practice. For example, previous research indicated that between 25 and 66 percent of lesbian or gay workers had experienced discrimination. Of the participants in this study, 37 percent said they had faced discrimination because others suspected or assumed they were gay or lesbian. More than 10 percent said they had been physically harassed. More than 22 percent said they had been verbally harassed. Nearly 31 percent said they had resigned from a job, had been fired from a job or had left a job because of discrimination.
Green added: “As other recent surveys have shown, the vast majority of Americans think that it is unfair to discriminate against people for personal characteristics that are unrelated to their actual job performance. For example, the May 2007 Gallup Poll reported that 89% of Americans believe that employment discrimination against lesbian and gay people should be illegal. For those whose job it is to shape employment policies in work settings and at all levels of government, the current study’s findings should be instructive. Safety in coming-out is good for workers and employers alike.”