Showing posts with label Cato Institute. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cato Institute. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 19, 2014

The "Libertarian Moment" Is Actually Being Engineered By The Christian Right


I have consistently maintained that the Christofascists and the Tea Party are largely one and the same.  The Tea Part label simply allows the Christofascists to hide their identity given how much they are despised by sane, decent citizens.  Less obvious, however, is the way in which the Christofascists are engineering the "libertarian moment" that Rand Paul seeks to capitalize upon.    A piece in Talk Points Memo looks behind the scenes of the libertarian movement to reveal the evil machinations of the Christofascists.  Here are some excerpts:
Unfortunately, to the extent there is something that can be called a “libertarian moment” in the Republican Party and the conservative movement, it owes less to the work of the Cato Institute than to a force genuine libertarians clutching their copies of Atlas Shrugged are typically horrified by: the Christian Right. In the emerging ideological enterprise of “constitutional conservatism,” theocrats are the senior partners, just as they have largely been in the Tea Party Movement, even though libertarians often get more attention. 

There is no universal definition of “constitutional conservatism.” The apparent coiner of the term, the Hoover Institution’s Peter Berkowitz, used it to argue for a temperate approach to political controversy that’s largely alien to those who have embraced the “brand.” Indeed, it’s most often become a sort of dog whistle scattered through speeches, slogans and bios on various campaign trails to signify that the bearer is hostile to compromise and faithful to fixed conservative principles, unlike the Republicans who have been so prone to trim and prevaricate since Barry Goldwater proudly went down in flames.

What a lot of those who instinctively think of conservative Christians as hostile to libertarian ideas of strict government persistently miss is that divinizing untrammeled capitalism has been a growing habit on the Christian Right for decades. Perhaps more importantly, the idea of the “secular-socialist government” being an oppressor of religious liberty, whether it’s by maintaining public schools that teach “relativism” and evolution, or by enforcing the “Holocaust” of legalized abortion, or by insisting on anti-discrimination rules that discomfit “Christian businesses,” has made Christian conservatives highly prone to, and actually a major participant in, the anti-government rhetoric of the Tea Party. Beyond that, the essential tea party view of America as “exceptional” in eschewing the bad political habits of the rest of the world is highly congruent with, and actually owes a lot to, the old Protestant notion of the United States as a global Redeemer Nation and a “shining city on a hill.”

So perhaps the question we should be asking is not whether the Christian Right and other “traditional” conservatives can accept a Rand Paul-led “libertarian” takeover of the conservative movement and the GOP, but whether “libertarians” are an independent factor in conservative politics to begin with. After all, most of the Republican politicians we think of as “libertarian”--whether it’s Rand Paul or Justin Amash or Mike Lee--are also paid-up culture-war opponents of legalized abortion, Common Core, and other heathenish practices. As Heather Digby Parton noted tartly earlier this week:
[T]he line between theocrats and libertarian Republicans is very, very faint. Why do you think they've bastardized the concept of "Religious Liberty" to mean the right to inflict your religion on others? It appeals to people who fashion themselves as libertarians but really only care about their taxes, guns and weed. Those are the non-negotiable items. Everything else is on offer.
And then there’s the well-known but under-reported long-term relationship of Ron and Rand Paul with the openly theocratic U.S. Constitution Party, a Con-Con inspirational font that no Republican politician is likely to embrace these days.

The more you examine the evidence, the more it seems plain that the “libertarian moment” in the GOP, even it’s real, and even if it’s advanced by Rand Paul as a presidential candidate, isn’t necessarily of a nature that’s going to be wildly popular among secular-trending millennials — or among Draper’s hipsters. To the extent it has a mass base, it’s likely as much or more among conservative Christian soldiers who despise government so long as they don’t control it as among dope-smoking free-loving free-thinking anti-interventionist Reason readers. So the latter might want to think twice before climbing onto the Rand Paul for President bus, or consigning their fate to Republican politics.

Monday, August 11, 2014

Embracing Libertarianism Will Not Save the GOP

There are some in today's Republican Party who claim that Libertarianism offers the best new hope for the GOP.  While there may be libertarians in the GOP, the bulk of the GOP base is the antithesis of the libertarian agenda of maximum personal freedoms with minimal government intervention.  It is no coincidence that the anti-gay agenda of the GOP base (and the political whores in elected GOP positions) flies directly against the arguments made by the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank, in amicus briefs which have sought to see state bans on same sex marriage invalidated.  The GOP base wants to regulate and control everything except for businesses/corporations.  True libertarians take a a 180% opposite position.  David Frum argues that the GOP is insane if it believes that embracing libertarian themes will save it from being anathema to most voters under 30.  Here are highlights:

Has the libertarian moment finally arrived? Robert Draper asks that question in the Sunday New York Times Magazine. His answer: Yes! Young voters are leaning libertarian, he says, and a Rand Paul presidential candidacy could energize those voters for the GOP.

Spoiler alert: Draper’s wrong, emphatically wrong. Young voters are not libertarian, nor even trending libertarian. Neither, for that matter, are older voters. The "libertarian moment" is not an event in American culture. It's a phase in internal Republican Party factionalism. Libertarianism is not pushing Republicans forward to a more electable future. It's pushing them sideways to the extremist margins.

Every serious study of the political attitudes of voters under 30 has discovered them to be the most pro-government age group since the cohort that directly experienced the Great Depression. Young voters are more likely than their elders to believe that government should intervene in the economy to create jobs. They support government aid to education and healthcare more than any other age group. Their voting behavior tracks their values: Under-30s massively voted for Barack Obama in 2008 and 2012.

The claim that young voters are trending libertarian rests on three principal data points:
  1. Young voters are more permissive on issues like same-sex marriage and drug legalization than their elders.
  2. Young voters are marginally less supportive of Medicare and Social Security in their present form than are older voters.
  3. Young voters are more alienated from institutions than their elders, including the two existing political parties.
But these points don’t add up to libertarianism. They don’t even present an opening to libertarianism. They reveal (modest) generational self-interest, social liberalism, and political demobilization.

Libertarianism is not rising in the country, but since 2009 it has exercised increasing influence inside the Republican party.  One measure of the libertarian rise is the waxing fortunes of the Paul dynasty

Despite the self-flattering claims of libertarians, the Republicans' post-2009 libertarian turn is not a response to voter demand. The areas where the voting public has moved furthest and fastest in a libertarian direction—gay rights, for example—have been the areas where Republicans have moved slowest and most reluctantly. The areas where the voting public most resists libertarian ideas—such as social benefits—are precisely the areas where the GOP has swung furthest and fastest in a libertarian direction.

Nor is it the strength and truth of libertarian ideas that explains their current vogue within the Republican Party. Libertarians have been most influential inside the GOP precisely where they have been—and continue to be—most blatantly wrong, such as when they predicted that the cheap money policies of the Federal Reserve would incite hyperinflation or that the United States teetered on the precipice of a debt crisis.

Libertarianism diverges from ordinary conservatism in many ways, but perhaps most fundamentally in this: Whereas ordinary conservatism emphasizes the inefficiency and ineffectiveness of government action, libertarianism presents government as alien and malign. 


Like all political movements, libertarianism binds together many divergent strands. It synthesizes the classical liberalism of the 1860s with the human-potential movement of the 1960s. It joins elegant economic theory to the primitive insistence that only metal can be money. It mingles nostalgia for the vanished American frontier with fantasies drawn from science fiction. It offers three cheers both for thrift, sobriety, and bourgeois self-control and three more for sex, drugs, and rock-and-roll.  It invokes the highest ideals of American constitutionalism—and is itself invoked by the most radical critics of the American state and nation, from neo-Confederates to 9/11 Truthers.

The libertarians interviewed by Robert Draper talk about their movement’s exciting, bold ideological vision. Yet the true secret to its post-2008 appeal is just the opposite. Those conservatives who succumb to libertarianism do so in despair, not hope. Instead of competing to govern the state, many now feel that their only hope is defend themselves—with arms if necessary—against an inherently and inevitably hostile and predatory state.

Conservatives who still want to compete, win, and govern must trust that this despair will pass. The “libertarian moment” will last as long as, and no longer than, it takes conservatives to win a presidential election again. Unfortunately, the libertarian moment is itself the most immediate and the most difficult impediment to the political success that will be libertarianism’s cure.

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

The Cato Institute: A Constitutional Case for Gay Marriage


While its libertarian agenda often leads it to side with extreme right wing Republicans who would dismantle government, when it comes to gay rights the Cato Institute is a great ally.  More than a decade ago the Cato Institute filed a brief in Lawrence v. Texas that called for the striking down of Texas' sodomy statute - and Virginia's sodomy statute by extension.  Now, the Cato Institute has filed an amicus brief with the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit in the appeal of Bostic v. Rainey which struck down Virginia's heinous Marshall-Newman Amendment.  A column in the Richmond Times Dispatch looks at the Cato Institute brief.   You can read the full brief here.  You can also read Cato's own page on the brief here.  Here are excerpts from the RTD column:

When liberals and conservatives argue they often talk past each other, deploying arguments that seem like winning ones to them but that the other side views as irrelevant or unimportant. So the Cato Institute has done a great service by filing a brief in Virginia’s gay marriage case that makes a conservative argument for the liberal position.

Bostic v. Rainey tests the constitutionality of Virginia’s amendment banning same-sex marriage. Cato is a libertarian think tank that infuriates and delights liberals and conservatives in roughly equal measure — by arguing for huge cuts in both entitlement spending and defense spending, by opposing both gun control and the war on drugs. It has enjoyed the support of liberalism’s bĂȘte noir, the Koch brothers. But it had a famous falling-out with them two years ago when the Kochs wanted the institute to take more partisan stands.
Cato’s brief in the Virginia case was written by Ilya Shapiro, with Elizabeth Wydra of the Constitutional Accountability Center. Filed this past Friday, it takes a conservative approach. It stresses the actual text and original intent of the Constitution, with special emphasis on the 14th Amendment.

That amendment, adopted after the Civil War, stipulates that states shall not deny “to any person . . . the equal protection of the laws.” This, says Cato, effected a profound change in the nature of the Constitution, “from one that sanctioned inequality to one that prohibited it.”

Notably, the equal-protection clause is not limited to “any black person” or “any straight person” but to any person, period. As one of its drafters, Rep. John Bingham, said, it insists that “all persons, whether citizens or strangers . . . have equal protection in every State in this Union in the rights of life and liberty and property.”

The brief goes on to argue that “the original meaning of the equal protection clause confirms” that it “applies broadly to all persons.” When he introduced the amendment in the Senate, Jacob Howard — so closely associated with the amendment it sometimes was called the “Howard Amendment” — stressed that it “abolishes all class legislation in the States and does away with the injustice of subjecting one caste of persons to a code not applicable to another.”


Marriage, Cato argues, is “a basic civil right of all persons” — one the Supreme Court described in Loving v. Virginia as a “vital personal right essential to the orderly pursuit of happiness.” It is not a privilege or a blessing conferred by the state, but an aspect of liberty: As Sen. Jacob Howard explained, “a slave ‘had not the right to become a husband or father in the eye of the law,” whereas “the attributes of a freeman according to the universal understanding of the American people” included “the right of having a family, a wife, children, home.” Cato quotes an African-American soldier: “In slavery we could not have legalized marriage: now we have it.”


But what of tradition? Traditionally, marriage has meant the union of one man and one woman. Well, Cato retorts, “no tradition can supersede the Constitution.” That is a direct quote from Justice Antonin Scalia in a 1990 case. A nice touch. Cato goes on to cite several other cases, all making the same point as Scalia did. “If a so-called tradition or history of discrimination were sufficient to justify perpetuating the discriminatory practice,” writes Shapiro, “our public schools, drinking fountains, and swimming pools would still be segregated by race. . . . Carving out of the text of the 14th Amendment an exception for traditional forms of discrimination would have strangled the Equal Protection Clause in its crib.”
Virginia enacted its marriage amendment specifically to prevent gays and lesbians from exercising a liberty exercised by straights. As Cato’s brief makes abundantly clear, it is precisely the sort of state-imposed discrimination against a caste of people the 14th Amendment was written to prevent.
 On a personal note, my husband and I consider ourselves within the category of "all persons."  We want and demand equality under the civil laws along with everyone else.