
*
The Roman Catholic Diocese of Bridgeport on Friday appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court to keep secret more than 12,600 court documents from priest sex-abuse cases. The 50-page writ, prepared by a New York law firm recently hired to handle the appeal, asks the court to overturn the state Supreme Court ruling that the files are public documents. The appeal hinges on two legal issues: the state Supreme Court's definition of what constitutes a legal document, and the church's contention that its First Amendment rights would be violated by unsealing documents that church officials produced with the understanding that they would be secret forever.
*
Among the court documents the diocese is striving to keep sealed are three depositions by then-Bishop Edward Egan, who was in charge of the Bridgeport Diocese when most of the lawsuits against priests under his control were filed and adjudicated. Egan recently retired as the archbishop of New York.
*
Four newspapers, including the Hartford Courant, filed a lawsuit to have the documents unsealed in 2002 when it was discovered that they had not been destroyed. The court ruled that all but 15 documents in the 23 separate files are public records. Those 15 documents, at least two of which are depositions, were not submitted as legal documents and will remain sealed, the court ruled.
*
If the Church leadership was truly contrite and wanted to insure that the errors of the past are never repeated, it would not be fighting tooth and claw to keep information sealed and secret. But, in my opinion, there is no true contrition on the part of the Church and its hierarchy. Their sole regret is that they got caught and that the news of the cover ups for sexual predators on a massive scale was exposed to the public. The ruined lives of thousands of victims of sexual abuse by Catholic clergy really means nothing to these nasty and out of touch frauds. And yes, that includes Benedict XVI who is as guilty as many others.
No comments:
Post a Comment