Negative reactions to Indiana's disingenuously named Religious Freedom Restoration Act continue, yet similar acts are making their way through legislatures in Georgia and Arkansas - Arkansas' governor has said he will sign the foul act if it gets to his desk - all in the supposed name of "protecting religious freedom." Such claims are a lie and are nothing less than an attack on the religious freedom of non-Christofascists and a special license to allow the "godly folk" to discriminate and mistreat others. A piece in
Patheos looks at the hypocrisy and lies behind these acts. Here are highlights:
There has been a firestorm in the media over the past 24 hours as
Indiana’s House of Representatives passed a bill that exempts
individuals and businesses from having to comply with the discrimination
rulings based on their religious convocations. At the same time in
Georgia, another RFRA (Religious Freedom Restoration Act) has been
approved by the House judiciary subcommittee and is rapidly moving
towards becoming law. Advocates are promoting both bills as necessary
legislation to bolster religious freedom and protect business owners and
private citizens from being forced to provide services to anyone that
they disagree with on the basis of their faith.
But embedded in this logic are a number of untruths that, when exposed,
unravel the entire argument. First, almost every state in the country already has comprehensive
and sufficient religious freedom protections. In no state is it viable
to suggest that a Christian pastor could face legal action if they
refuse to perform a gay wedding. Our first amendment rights alone offer
substantial coverage from such actions. However, it is true
that in many states, if a business owner refuses to extend their
business to a customer on the basis of religious beliefs, they could face legal action for discrimination, as they should.
Since the founding of our country, we have strived to be a nation that
upholds the fundamental dignity of every individual. Yet, when a lesbian
couple walks in to a bakery to order a cake for their wedding and is
turned away because of their sexual orientation, this act of
discrimination clearly undermines their equality and dignity as American
citizens and human beings. If a business owner believes that Islam is a
“false religion”, he could refuse to provide services to any Muslim
patron who walks through the door of his business. This too dehumanizes
individuals and reinstitutes principles of discrimination and
segregation. It is clear that these bills open Pandora’s box, allowing
for discrimination to flourish and setting back our country decades in
our progression towards equality.
Despite the fearful picture that is being painted by many legislators
and religious leaders about the future of our country once marriage
equality is passed, this reality remains true: The religious beliefs and
convictions of all Americans are fully protected by both national and
state law in all 50 states. No individual will ever be forced to promote
or renounce a religious belief and no churches will ever be made to
offer sacraments to those they deem unfit.
It is true, however, that
public businesses and corporations that serve the general public will be
required to offer fair and equal treatment and service to all people-
regardless of their race, creed, political party, religious affiliation,
sexual orientation, or gender identity. And it is this that new RFRA
bills are subversively trying to dismantle.
Can you imagine walking up to a store window and seeing a sign that
says, “No LGBTQ People Allowed”. Would you want to support that
retailer? What if it said, “No Jews Allowed”? This is essentially what
RFRA’s will allow businesses across their state to do, recreating the
climate that existed in our country prior to the Civil Rights Movement.
[E]ven though legislators in Indiana and Georgia are claiming to be
“bolstering the protection of religious liberty”, they’re really just
trying to legalize discrimination against LGBTQ and any other
individuals that they disagree with.
No comments:
Post a Comment