Dustin Lance Black - Academy Award winner for best screen play for the movie Milk and Board Member, American Foundation for Equal Rights ("AFER") - has a column at Huffington Post that makes the argument as to why NOW is the time to challenge anti-gay marriage amendments like Proposition 8 in the federal courts as opposed to waiting as some professional LGBT activist would have preferred (there certainly has been much back biting and condescension towards Black and others at AFER by some who believe only they should dictate how equality is won). Perhaps I'm biased because I had the opportunity to meet and talk with Dustin Lance Black at the National Equality March back in October. Or maybe I am merely the impatient type by nature who believes that gays have waited long enough to stop being treated as equal citizens. Or maybe it's because as an attorney, I believe the correct legal arguments and reading of the Constitution are on the side of the plaintiffs in Perry. In any event, I support the case going forward and I am thrilled by the legal team representing the plaintiffs. Here are some highlights from Dustin's column:
*
Over the past months I have had the pleasure and privilege of meeting the plaintiffs in Perry vs. Schwarzenegger. Their love is true, their families are strong, and to hear their stories is to know they deserve full recognition of their love, both for themselves and for their families. The time has come for the world to meet Kris Perry and Sandra Stier, Paul Katami and Jeff Zarrillo. Their stories are our stories, ones of finding love with another person, of overcoming adversity, and of the strength and importance of family.
*
But now their stories must take a place in history, next to Brown vs. Board of Education and Loving vs. Virginia, in order to confirm what our great Constitution already tells us is true: that separate is not equal, and that all men and women, regardless of skin color or sexual orientation, deserve equality.
*
To those who have said, "Wait," I say, Gay and Lesbian people should not be forced to wait years to be treated equally under the law. By straining to avoid our federal Constitutional arguments, we only reinforce the false notion that our arguments lack merit. We reinforce the lies and myths and stereotypes that have been forced upon us for generations. We send a signal that we must not truly believe we are equal. The truth is, we are equal, and our love deserves equal recognition and protection under the law. Truth is on our side, and justice, but time is not.
*
We cannot wait. We cannot wait for more children to be born into this country hearing that they are "less than," that this country considers them inferior or second class, that their love is not worth honoring. If we do, how can we ever expect them to contribute, to thrive, or even just to survive? We cannot wait for one more young person to hear this terrible news and take his or her own life, or have it brutally taken from them. Now is the time for this federal challenge.
*
To many of us, this challenge sounds like debate and politics, tedium and hard work, but to the young people out there who are afraid, who tune in and hear that we have taken this bold new step, it will sound more like: "You are not less than. You have brothers and sisters, gay and straight, black and brown and white, thousands of us. And your struggle is our struggle, and your fight is our fight, and very soon, we promise you, you will be equal citizens, and you will be free."
*
Over the past months I have had the pleasure and privilege of meeting the plaintiffs in Perry vs. Schwarzenegger. Their love is true, their families are strong, and to hear their stories is to know they deserve full recognition of their love, both for themselves and for their families. The time has come for the world to meet Kris Perry and Sandra Stier, Paul Katami and Jeff Zarrillo. Their stories are our stories, ones of finding love with another person, of overcoming adversity, and of the strength and importance of family.
*
But now their stories must take a place in history, next to Brown vs. Board of Education and Loving vs. Virginia, in order to confirm what our great Constitution already tells us is true: that separate is not equal, and that all men and women, regardless of skin color or sexual orientation, deserve equality.
*
To those who have said, "Wait," I say, Gay and Lesbian people should not be forced to wait years to be treated equally under the law. By straining to avoid our federal Constitutional arguments, we only reinforce the false notion that our arguments lack merit. We reinforce the lies and myths and stereotypes that have been forced upon us for generations. We send a signal that we must not truly believe we are equal. The truth is, we are equal, and our love deserves equal recognition and protection under the law. Truth is on our side, and justice, but time is not.
*
We cannot wait. We cannot wait for more children to be born into this country hearing that they are "less than," that this country considers them inferior or second class, that their love is not worth honoring. If we do, how can we ever expect them to contribute, to thrive, or even just to survive? We cannot wait for one more young person to hear this terrible news and take his or her own life, or have it brutally taken from them. Now is the time for this federal challenge.
*
To many of us, this challenge sounds like debate and politics, tedium and hard work, but to the young people out there who are afraid, who tune in and hear that we have taken this bold new step, it will sound more like: "You are not less than. You have brothers and sisters, gay and straight, black and brown and white, thousands of us. And your struggle is our struggle, and your fight is our fight, and very soon, we promise you, you will be equal citizens, and you will be free."
No comments:
Post a Comment