Thursday, July 29, 2010

The Vatican's Subculture of Gay Priests

Newsweek - that magazine one finds in countless doctors' office waiting rooms and other places - has jumped on the band wagon and is covering what is apparently an open secret in Rome, Italy - gay Catholic priests are literally everywhere and many date other gay priests in public view. The Vatican's latest reaction is to remain untethered from objective reality and demand that all such priests come out of the closet and leave the priesthood. Does this apply to Benedict XVI too who has long been rumored to have a "special friend"? And has anyone stopped to factor in that such a demand could lead to the Church's inability to function, much like what would happen to the U.S. Navy if all of the gays left? Of course not. Hypocrisy is the principal hallmark of institutional Catholicism today. Andrew Sullivan described the situation as such:
*
It is an institution so embedded with homosexuality it makes Broadway look straight. The stories I've heard! The network of gay priests is vast in Rome, and is, in my mind, as unhealthy for those who get away with it - the hypocrisy must hollow out the soul in the end - as for those who impose it. Instead of grappling with this fact, owning it, and seeking to diversify the priesthood by ending the celibacy requirement and men-only anachronism, the Vatican clings on to denial and repression.
*
Increasingly, on these issues of modernity, the Vatican of the new millennium seems like the Soviet Politburo of the 1980s. They pretend to believe what they preach while we pretend to obey them. One day, this surreality will pop like a bubble.
*
The Politburo comparison is especially appropriate since "do as we say not as we do" is so pronounced that the only way those trying to cling to the Church can remain is to become increasingly so-called cafeteria Catholics who ignore more and more of Rome's disingenuousness and also attend mass less and less frequently. What to y mind is so sad and downright criminal is that the Church hierarchy continues to ruin and warp young gay lives with its anti-gay jihad even as in cities such as Rome its priests enjoy an almost circuit party like atmosphere. Here are highlights from Newsweek:
*
In the basement dining room of Le Mani In Pasta, a trattoria in central Rome, a young, glossy-eyed couple stare at each other across a table for two. They smile and blush over a private joke. There is no handholding or kissing, but they are clearly more than friends, even though they are both wearing dark shirts and the telltale white clerical collar.
*
For residents of Rome, the sight of courting priests is hardly an anomaly. The phenomenon is a well-known secret here, and one that was largely ignored until last weekend, when the Italian weekly magazine Panorama published a shocking exposé called “Le Notti Brave Dei Preti Gay,” or “Good Nights Out for Gay Priests.”
*
The exposé has touched a nerve within the Catholic community in Rome, but Abbate doesn’t believe that it will have any effect, especially given the Vatican’s other sex scandal. Yet unlike the pedophile-priest crisis, which has so far reached scores of dioceses in the United States and Europe, the gay-priest problem is—so far—an issue just for the Rome diocese on the Vatican’s home turf. Most priests in Rome have some affiliation with the Vatican, and Abbate says one of the priests caught on tape also gave mass in St. Peter’s Basilica.
*
Victims’ rights advocates, however, have noticed that the Vatican seems more focused on sexual orientation than sexual deviance, and they are furious. While clergymen spent years covering up rumors of child-sex abuse and protecting each other, they’re calling instantly for the ouster of gay priests. “Priests who are committing sex crimes against children and bishops who enable and conceal the crimes are the ones leading double lives,” says Barbara Blaine, head of Survivors Network for those Abused by Priests. “They are the ones who should resign.”
*
But requirements like those are impossible to enforce, and they are plainly ignored. In Rome’s medieval quarter of Trastevere not far from Le Mani In Pasta, the International Ecclesiastic Seminary attracts men from all over the world who want to study for the priesthood in the heart of Rome. A professor there, speaking on the condition of anonymity to protect his job, says the vast majority of the young men who come to study are sexually active gay men who quickly become part of the lively gay culture in Rome.
*
Abbate also discovered through his covert research that male escorts and transsexual prostitutes in Rome rely on priests as regular customers. Last March, a member of the Vatican choir admitted to police that he arranged male escorts for papal assistants, including Angelo Balducci, a high-ranking member of Gentlemen of his Holiness, a fraternal order whose members assist the pope.
*
Bryan Cones, who writes for the popular U.S. Catholic blog. “On this matter, the church’s real problem is the closet,” he says. “I must agree with the Vicar of Rome that it would be helpful if gay priests would come out—so we could thank them for their faithful service, especially as they have been unjustly tarred with ‘causing’ sex abuse. Unfortunately, our church leadership at this time is not creating the kind of open and safe space that would allow for such honesty.”

1 comment:

Joseph Charles (J.C.) said...

Enjoyed reading your blog. I just wished more people in the world today could be educated about homosexuality; I've found that education preceeds acceptance and leads to the understanding that we are who we are!